Figure 1.--. |
|
The American Manhattan Program was initiated by President Roosevelt when work done by German physicists led to concern that the NAZIs might build an atomic bomb. Jewish and oher refugees fleeing the NAZIs made a major contribution to the success of the Manhattan Program. The first bomb was successflly tested at Alamagordo, New Mexico on July ??, 1945. The Allies met in a Berlin suburb after the NAZI surrender to make dcisions about the occupation of Germany and defeating Japan. The Allied powers 2 weeks after the bomb was tested demanded on July 27, 1945 that Japan surrender unconditionally, or warned of "prompt or utter destruction". This became known as the Potsdam Declaration. The Japanese military was prepared to fight on rather than surender. The Japanese Government responded to the Potsdam Declaration with "utter contemp". The Japanese military continued feverish pland to repel the Ameican invasion of the Home Islands. Many Whermacht generals at the end of the War were anxious to surrnder to the Amreicans. One German General commanding forces westof Berlin after the War said, "We wondered why they didn't come." This was not the attitude of the Japanese military. I know of know memoir written by an important Japanese military officer expresing similar sntiments. Truman was not anxious to use the atomic bomb. He was anxious to end the War and limit Ameican casulties. For Truman the Japanese response to the Potsdam Declaration made up his mind. There have been many books and aticles published in both Japan and America about the atomic bomb. Japanese scholars have reserched the decission making process that led to the dropping of the atomic bombs. Almost always the focus is on Truman and Ameican military leasers. Rarely do Japanese authors address the role of Japanese political and military leaders. The United States dropped two atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki on August 6 and 9, and the Soviet Union entered the war against Japan on August 8.
The American Manhattan Program was the largest weapons development program in history. It was initiated by President Roosevelt when work done by German physicists led to concern that the NAZIs might build an atomic bomb. Important scientists in 1939 concluded that German scienbtists had begun to develop an atomic bomb for the NAZIs. These scientists enduced President Roosevelt to launch an American atomic bomb project. The project was, however, given serious attention only after the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor bringing America into the war. General Leslie R. Groves (1896-1970), Deputy Chief of Construction of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, was assigned to oversee the project. The Manhattan Project us named after the New York borough where the first office headquarters was located and began June 1942. Groves had just completed another rush project, the construction of the Pentagon. He considered himself an astute judge of men and chose Robert J. Oppenheimer (1904-1967)to lead the scientific team. Oppenhimer was a respected, but reatively unknown theoretical physicist. Enrico Fermi and ?? Salard working in a converted squash court beneath the University of Chicago's carried out the first controlled nuclear reaction occurred confirming that nuclear fission could unleash huge amounts of energy. The major difficulty in building an atomic bomb was in obtaining the rquired quanity of fissionable material. A huge facility was built an Oak Ridge, Tennessee to separated the U-235 isotope needed for the bomb from the more common U-238 isotope. The Hanford Engineer Works was built in washington to produce plutonium. Groves chose Los Alamos, New Mexico as a location to acually develop and assemble the bomb or "gadget" a it was called. This ioslated town had by March 1943 been turned into a high-technology boomtown. The Y-12 Plant at Oak Ridge provided the bomb-grade U-235 used for the Little Boy bomb. The Harford plant provided the Plutonium used in the Fat Man bomb.
Jewish and oher refugees fleeing the NAZIs made a major contribution to the success of the Manhattan Program. The NAZI campaign against the Jews began almost as soon as Hitler seized power in Germany. Even respected sientists were quickly dismissed from positions at universites and research institutes. Many of these individuals were able to emmigrte and take of their carrers Americ, France, and Britain. This significantly increased the pool of talented sientists available tothe American atomic bomb program. Some of the vest known were Hans Bethe (Alsatian-German Jew), Albert Einstein (German Jew), Enrico Fermi (Italian with Jewish wife), Leo Szilard (Hungarian Jew working in Germany), Edward Teller (Hungarian Jew working in Germany), and Eugene Wigner (Hungarian Jew working in Germany). Many like Bethe did not look on themselves as Jews. Some authors believe that the dismissal of competent scientists and appointment of Party hacks was a major reason in the failure of the German bomb program. [Walker] Many of these nuclear scientists emmigrated early in the NAZI era when the NAZIs were primarily concerned with dismissing Jews from universities and other official positions. Fremi came much later and managed to escape with his wife when he was allowed to go to Sweden to accept a Nobel Prize.
The American conquest of the Marianahas Islands in the Pacific brought the Japanese Home Islands within the range of the new American B-29 bombers. The Army Air Corps began the strategic bombing campaign in November 1944. The initial bombing raids were inclonclusive. General Curtis LeMay devised a trategy of fire bombing which caused massive destruction in Japanese cities crammed with highly flameable wooden structures. Major cities like Tokyo were devestated. The resulting fire storms caused thousands of civilian deaths.
The invasion of Okinawa was the first American attack on Japanese territitory. Okinawa, in the Ryukyu Island chain was strategically located between Kyushu, the southernmost Japanese island and Taiwan (called Formosa by the Japanese). American strategists saw Okinawa as a necessary base from which an American invasion of the Japanese home islands could be staged. Okinawa had several air bases and the only two important harbors between Formosa and Kyushu. The American invasion was code named Operation Iceberg. The greatest naval force in histoy was assembled for the invasion. Admiral Raymond A. Spruance's 5th fleet included more than 40 aircraft carriers, 18 battleships, 200 destroyers and hundreds of support ships. Over 182,000 troops participated in the invasion. The American invasion forced was surprised when the beach landings were unopposed. Okinawa was defendened by the 32nd Japanese Army and a garrison of about
110,000 men. The Japanes had drawn back from the onvssion beaches. The Japanese strategy was to bring as many ships as possible in close to the island to support the invasion. it was then that a major Kamakazi attack was unleased on the invasion fleet. The Japanese on April 6-7 employed the first massed formations of hundreds of kamikaze aircraft. The Japanese during the Okinawan campaign flew 1,465 kamikaze flights from Kyushu. They succeedd in sinking 30 American ships and damaged 164 others. Other ships were attacked nearer Kyushu and Formosa. The Army Air Corps had rejected a request to havily bomb these air fields
as it was seen as a diversion from the strategic bombing campaign. One third of the invasion force was killed or wounded. Over half of the 16,000 Americans killed were sailors on the ships attacked by the Kamakazis. Virtually the entire Japanese garison died in the Okinawa campaign. Few Japanese soldiers surendered even after defeat was certain. Large number of civilans were also killed. The Jaoanese military reserved available food and supplies for its use and in many cases forced civilians to commit suicide. The American military saw Okinawa as a dress rehersal for an invasion of the Japanese Home Islands and anticipated even fiercer resistance. The extent of the casualties was a major factor in the American decission to use the atomic bombs.
Germany overrun from east and west surrendered to the Allies on May 8, 1945. The impetus for the Manhattan Project was the concern of European refugees that NAZI Germany was building an atomic bomb. The American bomb would be a deterent against a NAZI bomb. Few of the sciebtists involved at the time thought that the bomb would ever be ued or sed as it was, against the Japanese. When the NAZIs surrendered and it was soon determined that German work on an atomic bomb had not progressed very far, the initial rationel for the American atomic bomb no longer existed. Even so, only one scientist, Joseph Rockblatt, resigned from the project. He was quickly hustled out of Los Alamos by General Groves. [Cornwell]
The first bomb was successflly tested at Alamagordo, New Mexico on July 16, 1945.
The victorious Allies met in a Berlin suburb after the NAZI surrender to make dcisions about the occupation of Germany and defeating Japan. The Allied powers 2 weeks after the bomb was tested demanded on July 27, 1945 that Japan surrender unconditionally, or warned of "prompt or utter destruction". This became known as the Potsdam Declaration.
The Japanese military was prepared to fight on rather than surender. The Japanese Government responded to the Potsdam Declaration with "utter contemp". The Japanese military continued feverish pland to repel the Ameican invasion of the Home Islands. Many Whermacht generals at the end of the War were anxious to surrender to the Amreicans. One German General commanding forces west of Berlin after the War said, "We wondered why they didn't come." This was not the attitude of the Japanese military. I know of know memoir written by an important Japanese military officer expresing similar sntiments. Truman was not anxious to use the atomic bomb. He was anxious to end the War and limit Ameican casulties. A HBC reader writes, "As a world War II veteran, I would like to make a comment about the use of the atomic bomb on Japan. The estimated U.S. military casualties if we invaded Japan was approximately one million GI's. Iwo Jima an island that was three miles long and one mile wide at it widest had 6,000 marines killed and a casualty count of 25,000. My brother was wounded landing on Iwo Jima and still carries some shrapnel in his leg. Then remember Saipan and Okinawa where where we had huge losses of our GI's. Therefore, if we had to invade Japan how many of our Unted States population would never been born? In addition, Japan was using Kamikaza planes to destroy our aircraft carriers. Their military tradition was to die to the last man.
President Truman made the right decision."
One factor which must be consdered had America not dropped the bomb is the extent of Japanese casulaties, both military and civilian, had America invaded. Japanese readers writing to HBC suggest that Japan was defeated and there would not have been significant resistance. As far as we can tell, this appears to be the widespead Japanese public opinion on the issue rather than an assessment founded on historical research by recognized scholars. HBC would be interested in any Japanese or Western research substantiating the aseetion that Japanese resistance to an invasion of the home islands would have been inefectual. There is evidence that the Japanese military had stockpiled more than 5,000 aircraft for Kamakazi attacks when the invasion fleet came into range. The planes were well hidden from aerial attack in caves and other locations. The military was also feverously working on jets and other weapons with techhnology supplied by the NAZIs. There was also work on nuclear weapons and while Japan was far behind the Manhattan Project, they were fully capable of building a dirty bomb. One German U-boat with canisters of Uranium bound for Japan surendered to the Americans. American planners had no way of knowing if other U-boats got through. Another factor is the potential civilian casualties. Most of the War was fought in locations without important Japanese civilian populations. The exception was Saipan and to a much larger extent Okinawa. The Japanese military on both islands expected the civilians to resist the Americans and incouraged them to commit suiside rather than surrender. Had the Japanese military done the same on the Home Islands, the civilian casialties would have been enormous, dwarfing the libe lost at Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
For Truman the Japanese response to the Potsdam Declaration made up his mind. There have been many books and aticles published in both Japan and America about the atomic bomb. Japanese scholars have reserched the decission making process that led to the dropping of the atomic bombs. Almost always the focus is on Truman and Ameican military leaders. Many Japanese writers insist that Japan was a defeated country and would have surendered without the use of the bomb. Little real evidence is presented to substantiate the claim that Japan would have surendred. Rarely do Japanese authors address the role of Japanese political and military leaders. One American presidential adviser reports that Japanese reserchers and journlists have interviewed him a number of times during visits to Tokyo. They ask about when the decission was made to drop the bomb. He replies that it was the Japanese leaders who made the decission when they rejected the Potsdam Declaration. He says that this response is never included in either published articles or broadcasted television interviews. [Elsey] President Truman made the decession after a meeting with one of his most influential advisers, South Carolina Govenor Jimmy Byrnes (June 1). Byrnes told him that if he did not use the bomb that he would have to explain at his impeachment why he did not use a weapon that would have ended the War and saved tens if not hundreds of thousands of American lives. President Truman has never explained in detail why he decided to use te bomb. Certainly the military estimates of potential casualties from an invasion was a primary factor. Japanese resistance on Okinawa and Iwo Jima was strong evidence that American casualties woukd have been very substantial. Japanese brutality toward American POWs and civilians must have influenced the President, but to what degree it is difficult to tell. The possibility of the Soviet Union entering the War and claiming an occupation zone may have also been a factor. We are not sure just what intelligence briefings Truman received. One factor which would have been of concern was the Uranium shipments from Germany via U-boat. The only possible reason for such shipments was a Japanese nuclear project. One factor that does not seem to have influenced the President was limiting Japanese civilian casualties, but as horrible as the two bombs were, ending the War without an invasion probably save hundreds of thousands of Japanese lives, if not millions.
Many authors have criticised President Roosevelt and President Truman for demanding "unconditional surrender" from both the NAZIs and Japanese militarists.
The American and Germans were not the only countries with nuclear programs. The Brirish of course supported the American Manhattan Project. The Japanese also had a small program. It was conducted at Osaka University. It made only minor progress. The Japanese Army, however, developed a dirty bomb project. Here I do not know to what extent the Japanese developed this project or it was suggested to them by the Germans. We do know that the Japanese selected of all German war material and technology to have the Germans ship Uranium oxide to them by U-boat just before the NAZIs surrendered. The U-234 was dispacted (april 1945) with 50 lead cannisters with uranium oxide. Presumably this was accompanied with technical documentation. If so it was dicarded at sea by the U-boat captain along with two Japanese officers. Apparently the Japanses were planning to use the uranium oxide for a dirty bomb that was to be delivered by Japan's huge sunmarines that could actually launch aircraft. The suns had early stealth technology--rubber coated hulls. The attack was to hit San Francisco and was scheduled for August 17, 1945. Although the U-234 surrendered to the Americans, it was not known how many U-boats the NAZIs dispatched and how many got through with what cargos.
The United States dropped two atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki on August 6 and 9, 1945. The results were horendous. The Japanese were totally unprepared and had no idea what had ocurred. The humn tragedies are hear rending. There are many factual accounts. Many fiction writers have also addressed the cataclism. One particukarly moving fction account was about Emikio Amai ahe 6. "One morning toward the end of the summer they burned away by face. my little broither and I were playing oin the bank of the river." [Bock]
The Soviet Union, 2 days after the first atomic bomb was dropped, entered the war against Japan on August 8. Soviet armies rapidly swept through Manchuria, destroying the Japanese armies there. Some authors believe that the success of the Soviets in Manchuria and the inability of the Japanese army to resist them, had more of an impact on the Japanese military than the two atomic bombs. One factor that we are not yet sure about is why Japanese resistance in Manchuria colapsed so quickly and why the Japanese military commanders were willing to surrender to the Soviets, but unwilling to surrender to the Americans in Okinawa or the Philippines. The Japanese that surrendered to the Soviets spent years in the Gullag. They were used for years in construction projects in Siberia and Central Asia. [Solzhenitsyn, p. 84.] Only about half survived and ever returned to Japan.
The success of the Soviet Army convinced even many hard-line military officers that defeat was inevitable. Even so there were still hard liners that were determined to hold out. The military defense plan included using civilians to fight the Americans. This included wpmen and children. Children drilled with bamboo spears. A HBC reader as a little boy in primary scool remembers the bamboo speers. Some children were going to have explossive charges strapped on them. If this had been put into effect, the number of civilian cassualties would have been incalcuable. It is not clear wprecisely just when Emperor Hirohito decided that Japan must surrender. It seems that he came to this conclusion before the atom bombs were dropped, but did not know how to cinfront the military. The bombs and perhaps the success of the Soviets in Manchurchias, gave him the means of driving a wedge between the hard-liners and the rest of the militry high command. Even so, after it was learned that the Emperor planned to announce hi decission to surrender on the radio, die hards stormed the Imperial Palace in Tokyo, but were arrested by the palace guard who remained loyal. Emperor Hirohito on August 14 decided to surrender unconditionally. The formal surrender was held underneath the guns of the battleship USS Missouri in Tokyo Bay.
The United States after World War II oversaw an occupation which fundamentally changed the nature of both German and Japanese society. The American occupation in Japan rooted out Japanese militarism and fomenting the development of a democratic political regime and social structures. Women were enfranchized and labor unions allowed to organize.
The results by all practical measures have been an overwealming success. Japan today is one of the most prosperous and democratic societies in the world. There were, however, major differences in the occupation policies pursued in Germany. The Imperial Government was not dismantled. Emperor Hirahito was allowed to remain on the Crysanthumum Throne. Details on his involvement in the War suggest a participation that was far more extensive than
admitted at the time, although he certainly acted with considerable courage to end the War. Japan did not and does not today admit the full extent of its responsibility
for launching World War II. Many Japanese attempt to hide the extent of their country's war crimes. Here the list is long, led by the launching of aggerssive war first
against China (1937) and then the United States and Britain (1941). Specific examples include the terror bombing of undefended Chinese cities (Shanghai); mascres
of Chinese civilians (the Rape of Nanking), use of biologcal and chenical weapons, mistreatment and massacres of Allied POWs (the Batan Death March), abuse of
civilain internees, use of slave labor, conscription of civilian women for prostitution (Korean comfort women). Many Japanese today attempt to portray Japn in the
role of a victim of the War as a result of the atomic bomb. Right wing groups in Japan today are promoting a new curriculum about the War.
Bock, Dennis. The Ash Garden (Knopf, 2001), 281p.
Corwell, John. Hitler's Scientists: Science, War and the Devil's Pact.
Elsey, George. Panel discussion, Book-TV C-Span, November 14, 2002.
Solzhenitsyn, Aleksandr I. The Gulag Archipelago, 1918-56: An Experiment in Literary Investigation (Harper & Row: New York, 1974), 660p.
Navigate the Boys' Historical Clothing Web Site:
[Return to Main World War II Pacific campaign page]
[Return to Main World War II air campaign page]
[Return to Main military style page]
[Introduction]
[Activities]
[Biographies]
[Chronology]
[Clothing styles]
[Countries]
[Bibliographies]
[Contributions]
[FAQs]
[Glossaries]
[Satellite sites]
[Tools]
[Boys' Clothing Home]