The Sound of Music: Inaccuracies

Table 1.--Von Trapp Family. Actual ages and film ages

CHILD

MARRIAGE

FLIGHT

MOVIE

AGE

FIRST WIFE

Rupert (1911-92)

   16

  28

Liesel

  16

Agathe (1913- )

  15

  25

Friedrich

  14

Maria (1914- )

  13

  24

Louisa

  13

Werner (1915- )

  12

  22

Kurt

  11

Hedwig (1917- )

  10

  21

Brigitta

  10

Johanna (1919- )

  08

  19

Marta

  07

Martina (1921- )

  07

  17

Gretl

  05

MARIA
KUTSCHERA

Rosemarie (1928- )

  10

Eleonore (1931)

  07

Johannes

  NA*

* Born in America

A reader has pointed out the many inaccuracies in the 'Sound of Music'. "Regarding your Von Trapp Family and 'Sound of Music' pages, I recently did a bit of research about the von Trapp family, and found some interesting differences between the real family and the family as depicted in the film. (1) The father was not the martinet depicted in the play/movie but actually did a lot with his kids, including singing. This was one of the family's pet peeves with the play/movie "The Sound of Music." (2) Although the children were approximately the ages depicted in "The Sound of Music" when the Captain and Maria Kutschera married (Nov 26, 1927), they were almost 11 years older when the family fled Austria (June 1938). And by the time of the flight, Captain von Trapp and Maria had had two more children together, so there were nine "children" who fled, not seven, with "children" in quotes because the oldest, Rupert, was 28 at the time, and the others correspondingly older. (3) In real life the oldest child was a boy and the second oldest a girl; "The Sound of Music" -- presumably for dramatic reasons -- reversed that: the oldest is a girl, the second oldest a boy. I'm not sure what would have happened to the song "Sixteen Going on Seventeen" if the 16 year old had been a boy or if the sixteen year old girl had had a 17 or 18 year old big brother. (4) When they fled, the went on tour and never came back. Crossing the border suitcases in hand was better drama, but not the way it actually happened. I have prepared a table summarized the ages in the film and those portrayed in the film."











HBC







Navigate the Boys' Historical Clothing Web Site:
[Return to the Main Sound of Music page]
[Return to the Main "SM-SQ" movie page]
[Return to the Main English movie page]
[Introduction] [Activities] [Biographies] [Chronology] [Clothing styles] [Countries]
[Bibliographies] [Contributions] [Essays] [FAQs] [Glossary] [Images] [Links] [Registration] [Tools]
[Boys' Clothing Home]




Created: 8:13 PM 11/29/2013
Last updated: 8:13 PM 11/29/2013