Ladies Home Journal: "Good Taste and Bad Taste in Dressing Children" (1907)


Figure 1.-- The "Ladies Home Journal" tells mothers, "Look here, upon this picture, and on this! The girl with the doll is all ready to have a good play in clean or in dirty places and still be comfortable and happy."

We begin to see more informal styles for children in the 1900s than were common in the 19th century. Many children wre still dressed formally. We see Fauntleroy suits and Eton collars as well as ringlet curls. Even so there was a definite shift. The large lace and ruffled collars common in the late-19th century were not quite as large or as popular as in the 1890s. A much more pronounced shift would come in the 1910s, but still the beginning of a shift in attitudes about how children should be dressed was notable in the 1900s. We can see the beginning of the shift toward more casul wear for children in the photographic record. Casual garments like rompers and tunics were good examples of more informal styling that was becoming more popular for children. These more casual styles were especially popular for younger children. And we notice articles in popular magazines that addressed the issue. A good example is an article from The Ladies Home Journal in 1907 addressed the issue. The article discussed the issue of "over dressing childen", a common phenonenon in the 19th century and still very common in the early 20th century. Here is the text of the article. The author was not identified.

Figure 1

Look here, upon this picture, and on this! The girl with the doll is all ready to have a good play in clean or in dirty places and still be comfortable and happy. But her companion can't venture to have a good time where there is any “nice dirt" to play in, and looks thoroughly miserable in being so much overdressed, with a hat old enough for her mother, and furbelows and trimmings quite out of place on a child.

Figure 2

The first boy is in for a good time, and yet he looks the thorough little man with his bloomer trousers underneath his one-piece suit. Then look at his "nice" but unhappy little companion who is made a ridiculous caricature of a man in his wee trousers so out of place on little legs, in a hat which would look better on a girl than a boy, and a blouse, collar and tie that were surely meant for his sister.

Figure 3

Simple childish and yet undoubtedly smart is the dress of this little lady. Her white linen suit, shade hat, navy blue coat, her gloves and shoes, are all appropriate and inconspicuous. A girl of twelve wants to wear pretty clothes, of course, but she also wants to be able to "do things" in them, and they must not be "fancy," nor should they make her look older than she is. Her clothes must get their style from their cut and fit, and not from the trimming. She has many years before her to wear lace and jewelry—while she is a child she should dress like one!

Figure 4

Too much—too dreadfully much of everything! This girl's clothes probably represent greater money outlay than do those of the girl opposite, from the rhinestone buckle on her cap to her high heeled, patent leather shoes. Yet what is the effect? Cheapness, bad taste, unsuitability. Making a woeful attempt to look fine, she adds an elaborate lace collar to a plain cloth coat (which is all wrong), wears a skirt far too old for her in cut, dons fancy gloves, impressive beads, an exaggerated hair-bow, and a jingly metal belt—too much, indeed!


Figure 5.-- The "Ladies Home Journal" tells mothers, "Isn’t this a fine little fellow with his blue linen jumpers and his hobby-horse? And then look at the unfortunate little soul next to him, dressed so that he cannot have a moment's freedom."

Figure 5

Isn’t this a fine little fellow with his blue linen jumpers and his hobby-horse? And then look at the unfortunate little soul next to him, dressed so that he cannot have a moment's freedom. Our little friend with the hobby-horse is ready to get right down to play, and have a "bully" time, while the poor little fellow with the curls cannot have any fun at all, with his ridiculous hat, and his big Fauntleroy collar and jacket.

Figure 6

Comfortable and attractive is the little girl with the gingham dress, big rough-and-ready straw hat, and tan shoes and stockings. But the other poor child is dressed up in cast-off finery of her mother's, in hopeless imitation of her big sister. Her hat is much too old for her and so over trimmed that it looks like a lamp-shade, while her general appearance is that of being dressed out of the scrap basket.






HBC





Navigate the Boys' Historical Clothing Web Site:
[Return to the Main United States 1900s conventions page]
[Return to the Main United States 1900s page]
[Return to the Main United States early 20th century page]
[Introduction] [Activities] [Biographies] [Chronology] [Cloth and textiles] [Clothing styles] [Countries] [Topics]
[Bibliographies] [Contributions] [FAQs] [Glossaries] [Images] [Links] [Registration] [Tools]
[Boys' Clothing Home]




Created: 9:28 PM 5/26/2007
Last updated: 9:28 PM 5/26/2007